A quasi-experimental study of how GCSE maths grades are affected by school choices on tier of entry.
GCSE mathematics in England currently has two tiers of entry: foundation and higher. Foundation candidates can achieve GCSE grades 1 to 5. Higher tier entrants can achieve grades 4 to 9, with the potential for a grade 3 for students with marks just below the grade 4 boundary. Pupils whose marks on the higher tier are lower than this are ungraded.
In the older GCSE examination system, there was evidence that tiering may have capped the grades pupils achieved, yet there is a lack of evidence on whether this persists under new tier of entry arrangements.
The scoping study completed by SHU in 2025-26 found that a quasi-experimental evaluation could generate evidence about the impact of tier of entry practices on GCSE grades, complemented by evidence on how schools predict grades and make tier entry decisions, and how predicted grades and tier entry decisions are influenced by prior secondary mathematics experience. EEF is funding this study, which will use data from the National Pupil Database to examine the relationship between predicted grades, prior attainment, tier of entry and GCSE results. The report is due for publication in summer 2028.